What does under editorial review mean?

‘ Once the paper has come back from the reviewers, the AE goes through their comments to arrive at a decision on the paper, denoted by ‘Under Editor Evaluation’ or, as in this case, ‘Under Editor Review. ‘ [The AE then communicates their decision to the Editor-in-Chief (EiC), who makes the final decision on the paper.]

What is the difference between with editor and under review?

Answer: For most journals, a status change from “With Editor” to “Under review” would indicate that the paper has cleared the editorial check and has been sent for external peer review. You can check the journal’s website to see if the statuses they use have been mentioned.

What does manuscript under editorial consideration mean?

Here “Under consideration” means that your paper has passed the initial check and now it is assigned to an Associate Editor. It is at this stage the Associate Editor will decide whether it is necessary for the paper to enter the peer-review process.

What means required reviews completed?

When the status shows “Required reviews completed,” it means that the reviews have come in. However, because the reviews were usually quick, it does not necessarily mean that the decision will also be quick. Generally, journals receive a large number of submissions and the editor has to handle multiple submissions.

What does it mean when an article is under review?

Answer: For most journals, the status “under review” is used to indicate that the paper has cleared the editorial check and has been sent for external review. If there is no change for more than a few weeks, politely write to the journal editor asking about the status of your submission.

What does review completed mean?

5 Answers to this question. Answer: This is quite simple. Reviews Completed means that the peer review of the manuscript is complete. The associate editor (AE) will now make a first decision on the manuscript and share this with you shortly.

What is required reviews completed?

“Required reviews completed” essentially means that the minimum number of reviews required by the journal are completed. It does not mean that the journal editors have gone through the reviews yet. This status could also mean that editors have called for additional reviews, which is also common.

What does it mean if your paper is under review?

What is meaning of under review?

Definition of under review : being officially examined The policy is under review.

Why multiple changes in required review completed date?

Answer: The status changing to “Under review” once again after “Required reviews completed” indicates that the editor has sent your paper for an additional review. This is quite a common scenario.

What does it mean when a manuscript is under review?

Under Review: This status means that the manuscript is under peer review. Peer reviewers are busy scientists, and peer review is an honorary service that requires detailed scrutiny and evaluation of the manuscript. Hence, this is perhaps the most time-consuming part of the entire publication process.

How to track the status of your manuscript submission?

Manuscript submission has surely become quicker and more efficient with the help of online submission systems. These systems have a tracking feature that helps authors track the progress of their manuscripts by the status displayed on the interface. However, authors sometimes find the status changes confusing and get worried.

What happens when a manuscript is rejected from a journal?

If the manuscript does not match the scope of the journal or does not meet the standards of the journal, it will be returned without review. In such cases, it might show “Decision in Process” as the next status, and in all probability, the author will be informed of the rejection in a few days.

How long does the author have to submit the revised manuscript?

The author is usually given a deadline of a few weeks to a couple of months depending on the nature of revisions and the field of study. The author can request that the deadline be extended by writing to the editor in advance. The author needs to submit the revised manuscript along with a point-by-point response to the reviewer comments.